"Until this moment, Senator, I think I never gauged your cruelty or your recklessness... Let us not assassinate this lad further, Senator. You've done enough. Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?" Joseph Welch, June 9th, 1954 to US Senator Joseph McCarthy.
As I've gotten older I've come to realize that politics isn't pleasant. There's no such thing as a "mud" free campaign, you're always going to dig up dirt on your opponent, and when you find something, as long as it's true, I understand the need to use it. Don't get me wrong, I wish that it weren't so, I wish that candidates could have an honest debate about real issues, and not talk about past indiscretions. But I know that's not how it's going to be, and I've come to grips with that.
It's the same thing with punditry… Frequently both the right and left talking heads and blogs discuss policy, ideas, and the like, but there are occasions when both sides get into name calling. I'm fine with this as well, heck most of the time it's quite funny, and I regularly read the more "snarky" websites (see both Sadly No! and The Rude Pundit for excellent examples). The name calling is lobbed by each side at the other and it's a game where everyone knows the rules, and while there are always a few who take it seriously, most understand how it goes. Again no problem with that...
But in much the same way that the House Un-American Activities Committee quickly went off the rails, I'm afraid that some in the right wing punditry class have not only gone off the rails, but have crashed through the neighborhood and into the school. By now most are aware that a couple of weeks ago the Democratic response to Mr. Bush's weekly radio was given by 12 year old Graeme Frost. Young Master Frost told how having SCHIP paid for the medical bills his family faced after a severe accident. We can all discuss SCHIP, we can even discuss wither or not it was wise for Democrats to have a 12 y/o read its response (though please spare me the moral outrage of "Democrats using children", as Republicans do it as well [see Mr. Bush having "snowflake babies" surround him while vetoing the stem cell research bill for the most recent example]), but that wasn't good enough for the Right Wing Professional Punditry Class. No, rather than discuss the merits of the issues, they
go
after not only the family but the kid as well. They question their medical history, job history, how they educate their children, there is nothing that is out of bounds to them. All of which leads me to wonder – What the fuck is wrong with these people?
It's ironic that the same people who loudly decried criticism of a 4 star US Army soldier are stalking a middle class family, including but not limited to publishing their home address and driving by their places of business! Look, a lot of Right-Wingnuttery makes me angry, and all of this more so than ever before, but I would NEVER EVEN CONSIDER doing this to the likes of Steyn or Malkin or the rest of that ilk. There are some boundaries that shouldn't be crossed, and some rails that should always be stayed on! What the hell happened to these "people" that would make them do this? Have they become so angry that they don't consider slandering a middle class family or their children to be wrong? Have they become so driven by hate that anything, ANYTHING, they consider wrong is to be destroyed completely? "At long last, have (they) left no sense of decency?"
PS – I'm reminded of the penultimate scene in "The American President" (a schlocky love story, but not a bad movie). After quietly enduring reports and character questions about his girlfriend, "Andrew Shepherd" finally responds with a pretty good shot that I'm going to paraphrase here;
"The Frost family has done nothing to you... They have done nothing but be in a "traditional" marriage, raised two kids through a pretty tragic accident, they've bought a house and paid their taxes, in short they've lived what most on the Right consider to be a "correct" life. You guys want a character debate? You better stick with me, 'cause Graeme and his family are way out of your league…"